Welcome to our new website! We've virtually remodeled the place to better serve you! Please leave us feedback in our after checkout survey! Happy Gaming :)

Featured Magic

View as:
  • Moderately Played, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 17.59
    Moderately Played, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 17.59
    Moderately Played, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 17.59
  • Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 9.99
    Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 9.99
    Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 9.99
  • Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 22.99
    Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 22.99
    Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 22.99
  • Near Mint, English 4 In Stock
    CAD$ 12.99
    Near Mint, English 4 In Stock
    CAD$ 12.99
    Near Mint, English 4 In Stock
    CAD$ 12.99
  • Lightly Played, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 17.09
    Lightly Played, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 17.09
    Lightly Played, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 17.09
  • Lightly Played, English 4 In Stock
    CAD$ 22.49
    Lightly Played, English 4 In Stock
    CAD$ 22.49
    Lightly Played, English 4 In Stock
    CAD$ 22.49
  • Near Mint, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 10.99
    Near Mint, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 10.99
    Near Mint, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 10.99
  • Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 29.99
    Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 29.99
    Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 29.99
    Lightly Played, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 26.99
  • Lightly Played, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 8.09
    Lightly Played, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 8.09
    Lightly Played, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 8.09
  • Near Mint, English 4 In Stock
    CAD$ 8.49
    Near Mint, English 4 In Stock
    CAD$ 8.49
    Near Mint, English 4 In Stock
    CAD$ 8.49
  • Near Mint, English 3 In Stock
    CAD$ 69.99
    Near Mint, English 3 In Stock
    CAD$ 69.99
    Near Mint, English 3 In Stock
    CAD$ 69.99
  • Lightly Played, English 8 In Stock
    CAD$ 9.89
    Lightly Played, English 8 In Stock
    CAD$ 9.89
    Lightly Played, English 8 In Stock
    CAD$ 9.89
  • All variants Out of stock. CAD$ 8.49 Wishlist
    All variants Out of stock.
    CAD$ 8.49 Wishlist
    All variants Out of stock Wishlist CAD$ 8.49
  • Near Mint, English 3 In Stock
    CAD$ 21.99
    Near Mint, English 3 In Stock
    CAD$ 21.99
    Near Mint, English 3 In Stock
    CAD$ 21.99
  • Near Mint, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 13.99
    Near Mint, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 13.99
    Near Mint, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 13.99
  • Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 36.99
    Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 36.99
    Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 36.99
  • Near Mint, English 4 In Stock
    CAD$ 8.99
    Near Mint, English 4 In Stock
    CAD$ 8.99
    Near Mint, English 4 In Stock
    CAD$ 8.99
  • Near Mint, English 3 In Stock
    CAD$ 12.99
    Near Mint, English 3 In Stock
    CAD$ 12.99
    Near Mint, English 3 In Stock
    CAD$ 12.99
  • Near Mint, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 10.99
    Near Mint, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 10.99
    Near Mint, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 10.99
  • Lightly Played, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 17.09
    Lightly Played, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 17.09
    Lightly Played, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 17.09
  • Near Mint, English 3 In Stock
    CAD$ 69.99
    Near Mint, English 3 In Stock
    CAD$ 69.99
    Near Mint, English 3 In Stock
    CAD$ 69.99
  • Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 19.99
    Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 19.99
    Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 19.99
  • Damaged, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 5.57
    Damaged, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 5.57
    Damaged, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 5.57
  • Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 21.99
    Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 21.99
    Near Mint, English 1 In Stock
    CAD$ 21.99
  • Near Mint, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 10.99
    Near Mint, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 10.99
    Near Mint, English 2 In Stock
    CAD$ 10.99
  • 280 Geneva Street Rear Unit
    St. Catharines, ON L2N 2E8
  • 2893624401
  • info@thetoytrove.com
  • Mon: 11:00 am - 4:00 pm
    Tue: 11:00 am - 7:00 pm
    Wed: 11:00 am - 7:00 pm
    Thu: 11:00 am - 7:00 pm
    Fri: 11:00 am - 7:00 pm
    Sat: 11:00 am - 7:00 pm
    Sun: 11:00 am - 5:00 pm
  • Paypal